Tourists see Chocolate World; residents eat much better. Fenicci's on W Chocolate Avenue — Hershey's oldest restaurant, running since 1935 — is famous for its 'upside-down' pizza with the cheese underneath the sauce. The Hershey Pantry on E Chocolate Avenue has been voted Central PA's best breakfast for two decades (the stuffed French toast is the order). Tröegs Independent Brewing on Hersheypark Drive is a statewide beer destination with a scratch snack kitchen.
The upscale tier runs deep for a town this size: Devon Seafood + Steak in the historic Hershey Press Building, The Mill's scratch cooking in a restored 19th-century feed mill, The Circular and Trevi 5 at The Hotel Hershey, and Revelry's chophouse at the Lodge. New in March 2026: Hershey Social, the smash-burgers-and-darts reboot of the old Houlihan's corner at Cocoa and Chocolate.
Cherry Blossom Creamery on E Chocolate Avenue — the town's only handmade ice cream shop — closes the loop. Derry Township buyers: this is the daily life behind the school district ratings.
Hershey FAQs
- What is Hershey's oldest restaurant?
- Fenicci's of Hershey, on West Chocolate Avenue, operating since 1935 and famous for its 'upside-down' pizza with the cheese layered beneath the sauce.
Have a question about Hershey? Talk to an agent who sold there this month — call (717) 790-1847 or use the form below.